Deliciously Simple Frozen Yogurt Ninja Creami Recipe

Frozen yogurt Ninja Creami recipes are honestly a lifesaver for those moments when you just want a sweet treat but can’t be bothered with a ton of work or cleanup. You ever get that random itch for something cold and creamy (happens to me on the hottest afternoons)? Plus, dragging yourself to a froyo shop just for one bowl is… ugh, not happening. If you have a Ninja Creami sitting in your kitchen, maybe you’ve already tried a few recipes. If not, check out these great ideas: this epic best Ninja Creami protein ice cream or a super cozy easy Ninja Creami vanilla ice cream recipe. Today, I’m spilling the details on my favorite strawberry frozen yogurt for the Ninja Creami. It’s simple, it’s fast, and packed with bright strawberry flavor.

Print

Ingredient Notes

Okay, let’s talk basics. For this frozen yogurt Ninja Creami recipe, you’ll need just a few things, and yes, most are probably already in your fridge. Plain Greek yogurt is my MVP. Tangier than regular yogurt, gives that real froyo zing. Fresh strawberries? Always best, but frozen sliced berries work in a pinch (who hasn’t found a bag wedged in the freezer from last spring?). You want the brightness, not mushy fruit.

Sweetener is sort of up to you. I use honey most days because it plays well with strawberries, but maple syrup or regular old sugar will do in a fix. Taste as you go, honestly. That’s my hot tip. Splash of vanilla for the wow factor, if you’re feeling wild. Maybe a pinch of salt (tiny, I mean it, just to make the flavor pop). Keep it unfussy. That’s half the fun.

Expert Tips

Here’s where I spill all my secrets, because I’ve made this frozen yogurt Ninja Creami recipe way too many times (no shame). First, don’t skip blending your strawberries. I tried chopping them by hand once… Chunks. Everywhere. Too icy. A quick blitz in the blender really brings everything together.

Chill your mixture in the fridge before you freeze it (an hour is good). Don’t get antsy like me that one time—went straight to the freezer and got rock instead of cream. I can’t stress enough: the colder your base when you use the Ninja Creami, the smoother the end result. Use full-fat Greek yogurt for max creaminess. I know, lighter yogurt sounds diet-friendly, but trust me, the taste isn’t the same. Oh, and don’t worry if it looks a bit icy at first, just respin it in the machine. Magic.

“This frozen yogurt made in my Ninja Creami is now my nightly treat! It’s tangy, packed with real strawberry flavor, and tastes better than anything store-bought. So fast and easy my kids make it themselves after dinner.” — Robin T, Tulsa

Variations / Substitutions of Frozen Yogurt Ninja Creami

If you’re the kind of person who likes to mix it up (my hand’s up here), there’s loads of wiggle room with this frozen yogurt Ninja Creami treat. Want a dairy-free version? Try coconut yogurt. It’s got a tropical kick that honestly makes strawberries taste ten times fresher. If you run out of honey, agave syrup is a quick switch. Not into strawberries? Use blueberries, raspberries, mango—a berry mix, go nuts.

Feeling extra healthy? Toss in a scoop of protein powder. Or sneak in a handful of spinach. No, really. It’ll turn your yogurt green, but the strawberry taste holds strong. You haven’t lived until you’ve tried mango ice cream Ninja Creami either, by the way. Same process, new flavor world. Want it less sweet? Cut the sweetener, or skip entirely and top with fruit later.

Mix-in Ideas & Variation Ideas

Oh, this is the fun bit. Once your frozen yogurt Ninja Creami mix is spun and creamy, mix-ins take it from “wow” to “can I have seconds?”

• Toss in dark chocolate chunks for bite and richness.
• Swirl in a spoonful of peanut butter or almond butter.
• Handful of crushed graham crackers, pretzels, or granola—crunchy heaven.
• Top with more fresh strawberries, or drizzle with jam for double berry power.

Go wild. Your bowl, your rules.

Directions for Making Frozen Yogurt Ninja Creami

You ready for how easy this is? Blend your strawberries, yogurt, sweetener, and vanilla until nice and smooth. Taste and adjust, because everyone’s sweet tooth is different. Pour the blend into your Ninja Creami pint, and let it chill out in the freezer until solid—usually overnight, but I cheat and do at least 6 hours if I’m desperate.

Pop that frozen base into your Ninja Creami machine. Use the ‘Lite Ice Cream’ function, if yours has it. After the first spin, peek inside. Looking a little crumbly? Do a “Respin.” Suddenly, it’ll turn dreamy and smooth, I swear. If you want to go all in, throw in your favorite mix-ins and give it one last quick spin on “Mix-In.”

Conclusion

Go Try Strawberry Frozen Yogurt Tonight!

That’s it. Scoop, eat, and do a little happy dance. (Side note: kids love helping with this step. Watching that creamy froyo swirl out—never gets old.)

So, there you have it. Making frozen yogurt Ninja Creami is less a recipe, more a way of life once you taste how easy it is. Play with your favorite mix-ins and get creative. If you’re loving these flavors, peek at this vanilla ice cream Ninja Creami or explore more Ninja Creami recipes for inspiration. I also loved reading this Strawberry Frozen Yogurt (Ninja Creami) post—it’s packed with ideas, as is this Easy Ninja Creami Frozen Yogurt (High protein), especially if protein is your jam. Get that freezer working and treat yourself tonight—you genuinely deserve it.

Frequently Asked Questions