ninja creami peanut butter ice cream

Ever crave a big, creamy bowl of ninja creami peanut butter ice cream but panic at the idea of complicated steps or weird ingredients? You’re definitely not alone. Honestly, that was me, before I learned just how easy it can be to whip up at home. You get full peanut buttery flavor, a crazy-smooth texture, and hey, you control what goes in. If you’ve nosed around for more nutty goodness, you might wanna peek at this peanut butter cup protein ice cream recipe too (yum). Oh, and if you want a high-protein twist, check out the best Ninja Creami protein ice cream ideas while you’re here.

Print

Why you’ll love this peanut butter ice cream

Alright, full disclosure: I am not a patient cook. I want big payoff, minimum hassle. This ninja creami peanut butter ice cream is the definition of that. Just scoop, spin, and dig in. You get that childhood thunder-jolt of salty-sweet peanut butter from every bite. If you’re bored with basic vanilla, this flavor is off-the-charts better. My family basically swarms the kitchen when they hear the Creami running (I’m not kidding). Plus, you can mix in chunks, swirls, or whatever’s left in a snack bag—nobody’s judging. Forget expensive store flavors. Homemade wins, period.

Tips & Tricks

Ignore the fancy lingo, here’s what actually matters. Always use creamy peanut butter, not the old loaf of natural stuff that separates (unless you’re into runny disasters). Room temp milk blends better—cold milk can clump things up. Sweetener? Pick your favorite. I’ve tried honey, regular sugar, even that monk fruit stuff. All good, just taste as you go. Don’t rush the freeze; eight hours minimum in the Creami cup or you’ll regret it. If it looks crumbly after spinning, splash a spoon of milk in and respin. Respinning is a miracle. Also, save the mix-ins until the very end or they’ll all sink to the bottom. The Creami is sturdy but don’t try to stuff bananas, cookies, and marshmallows all at once. Less is more there (trust me, learned it the hard way).

How to Make Ninja Creami Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Okay, here’s the fun part. To start, grab a small bowl and stir your peanut butter with sweetener and a splash of milk until it’s nice and smooth. Pour the rest of your milk in, stir it up well, and check for taste—maybe you want more sweetness, me too. Pour it into your Ninja Creami container, slap the lid on, and pop it in the freezer for at least eight hours. This is the hardest part, promise.

Once it’s frozen solid, load it into your Ninja Creami machine. Use the “ice cream” setting. When it’s done, check your texture. If you see a powdery mess (been there), add a tablespoon of milk and use the “respin” button. Voilà—now you’re in business. Now’s when you add chocolate chips, sandwich cookies, or swirl in extra PB. Spin one more time on “mix-ins” if you want. That’s your ticket to legit, five-star restaurant creaminess.

Tools to make this easy peanut butter ice cream

There’s no secret gear here, pinky swear. First, you need a Ninja Creami machine. You also need the matching pint container (these seem to vanish in my house). A sturdy spoon for mixing the base, and that’s about it. Measuring cups sure help if you don’t want “oops, too salty again” moments. Oh, and if your family is like mine, maybe buy extra containers (they’ll all want their own flavor combo). My pro tip: keep an extra Creami paddle handy, cleaning is easier when you’re not waiting.

Substitutions

You’re not stuck with the classic. No peanut butter? Almond butter, sunflower butter, or even Nutella (yes, it works) can jump in just fine. If milk’s a problem, oat milk or almond milk make solid backups. Lactose-free milk does the trick too, for sensitive tummies. If you cut sugar, try maple syrup or low-calorie sweeteners. Vegan folks—I’ve heard coconut cream makes a rich, dreamy base, but honestly I prefer the lighter vibe with almond milk. What matters most? Don’t overthink it. Use what you love and you’re golden.

Peanut Butter Nutrition

So, here’s the scoop (pun intended). Peanut butter is more than just tasty. It packs in protein—about 8 grams for two tablespoons. Plus, you get filling healthy fats, and it’ll actually keep you full for a while, unlike those airy, store-bought tubs. There’s potassium, magnesium, and even some fiber in the deal. Go easy though… it does pack calories, so if you add extra, don’t eat the whole pint unless you’re feeling wild (or had a rough week; I get it).

I honestly never thought I could make ice cream this smooth at home. My kids ask for it every week now. Huge win, especially with how easy it is!
— Rita, actual real-life mom from Ohio

Ready To Dive Spoon-First Into Peanut Butter Heaven?

Making ninja creami peanut butter ice cream is honestly a total game-changer for any dessert lover. To recap, grab your basic ingredients, mix smart, freeze solid, and trust your Creami to do the magic. Experiment with flavors or swing by this classic vanilla ice cream Ninja Creami tutorial if you like things simple. If you want even more inspiration, check out these monster lists of tasty Ninja Creami recipes or visit this legendary Ninja Creami Peanut Butter Ice Cream recipe from I Dream of Ice Cream. So, don’t be shy—grab your Creami, try it out, and let your freezer do the work. I promise it’ll be worth every chilly, scrumptious bite.

FAQ about ninja creami peanut butter ice cream