Creamy Vegan Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream You’ll Love

Okay, let’s get into it. You know the drill: you finally pick up a groovy new Ninja Creami, you wanna make something creamy (like the ice cream you used to chase down as a kid, before you cared if it had protein or not). And then you realize — vegan, high-protein ice cream? It sounds impossible, right? That’s where vegan ninja creami protein ice cream comes in swinging. If you’re like me and constantly hunting new ways to get that sweet, smooth, five-star-restaurant-tasting frozen treat without wrecking your nutrition or your plant-based morals, you’re in luck. I learned so much fancy stuff while scrolling through the best Ninja Creami protein ice cream ideas — and, wild twist, there’s even a cottage cheese ice cream Ninja Creami version for curious folks (not vegan, but hey, options!). Anyway, let’s skip the sales pitch. Ready for treats that’ll make your blender jealous?

Print

Ingredients for Vegan Protein Ice Cream

You don’t need a pantry full of magic potions here. Classic vegan ninja creami protein ice cream always starts with a good plant-based milk. Oat milk gives the softest results, almond works too but don’t expect the same creamy hug.

Of course, you’ll want your favorite vegan protein powder. Chocolate or vanilla, totally up to you (but oh man, the chocolate one gets close to sinful). I always reach for a pea protein blend because soy makes my stomach grumble in protest.

Here’s the fun part: sweetener. Maple syrup if you’re a New Englander at heart (or like that vibe), or you can use agave, monk fruit, whatever tickles your tastebuds. A pinch of salt deepens the flavor, trust me, and a dash of vanilla brings everything together like socks at Christmas.

For best results, I stir in some cocoa powder (for chocolate cravings) or fresh berries if I’m feeling wild. That’s basically all. Feels like cheating how easy it is.

This recipe changed my snack game completely. I never thought vegan protein ice cream could be so rich and SO satisfying. My daughter makes it when she’s home from college — that’s my sign it’s a winner. – Marisol P., real-life ice cream skeptic

How to Make Vegan Chocolate Protein Ice Cream

Making vegan ninja creami protein ice cream is the opposite of fancy cooking. Even a sleep-deprived raccoon could pull this off.

Pour your plant milk directly into the Creami pint (don’t overthink it — use the fill line!). Add a scoop or two of vegan protein powder. Dump in a couple tablespoons cocoa powder, a glug of maple syrup, and a splash of vanilla. I stir it all up, and if you’re fancy, blend it for extra smoothness. Otherwise, a fork works just fine.

Now, here’s the part everyone forgets: let it chill. Literally. Put the mixture in your Creami pint, freeze it solid overnight. No peeking.

Next day, twist the pint into your Ninja Creami machine and hit the “Ice Cream” button. Blast it. You might need to respin if it’s still crumbly, just add a tablespoon of milk. Suddenly, you get that classic frozen swirl. Scoop it straight into a bowl, faceplant optional.

Possible Substitutions for Protein Powder

Sometimes — whoops — you open the cabinet and discover you’re flat out of protein powder. Honestly, vegan ninja creami protein ice cream gets creative here.

Oat flour thickens up the base pretty well, especially with peanut butter and a little extra sweetener. Silken tofu (sounds wild, but nobody ever notices) is surprisingly creamy, though you’ll want to blend it smooth or your ice cream might turn out a little weird — like, grainy. Not in a cute way.

And hey, if you’re tired of chocolate or vanilla, try Ninja Creami peanut butter ice cream for a twist. The basic method is the same, just sub in new flavors when inspiration strikes. If you’re serious about protein? Sneak in some chia seeds or hemp hearts.

Tips for Using the Ninja Creami

Real talk: I made a complete mess the first time I tried this. If your ninja creami protein ice cream turns out icy, here’s what works:

• Don’t skimp on fat. Use creamier plant milks like oat or coconut.
• If your mixture’s not smooth after the first spin, add a splash more milk and respin.
• Clean your Creami parts right after, otherwise the dried ice cream turns into cement.
• Add mix-ins after the first spin — chocolate chips, berries, heck, cookie dough if you dare.

Give it time in the freezer. Rushing is the sworn enemy of creamy texture.

More High Protein Vegan Treats

If you’re anything like me, one bowl of vegan ninja creami protein ice cream leads to another… and another. So if you want to mix things up, I’d peek at these 7 delicious Ninja Creami protein recipes. More variety, more protein, less boredom.

Vanilla fans, get yourself over to the easy Ninja Creami vanilla ice cream recipe. Mango people, yes, you guessed it, there’s mango Ninja Creami waiting for you too. Sometimes I top my ice cream with berries and a handful of nuts for maximum snack attack.

Oh, and for the true experimenters, check the top Ninja Creami recipes protein rich. Endless ways to keep your protein (and taste buds) up.

Ready to Make Your Own Bowl of Awesome?

See? Making vegan ninja creami protein ice cream is way easier (and honestly, more fun) than hunting down fancy cartons at the store. Don’t be scared to play around with flavors or protein types — you could lean into chocolate, try some wild add-ins, or even copycat faves like 5-Ingredient Vegan Chocolate Protein Ice Cream (Ninja Creami). If you need even more inspiration, dive into delicious Ninja Creami recipe ideas. Either way, your next frozen treat just got a seriously healthy upgrade. Have at it — let your freezer surprise you.

FAQ about Vegan Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream